Tips for an Effective Character Letter To a Judge in California
November 3, 2023 | Ahmed & Sukaram, Attorneys at Law
Addressing a character letter to a judge is not a trivial task—it has the potential to significantly impact the final decision in favor of the defendant. Before you start writing your character reference letter for court proceedings in California, it’s helpful to understand what exactly the purpose of the letter is and to review some tips that will help you make it as effective as possible.
Understand the Purpose of a Character Letter
A character letter plays a dual role. First, it is there to showcase your credibility as someone who knows the defendant well enough to speak on their character. It’s important to come across as sincere and dependable in the eyes of the judge evaluating the letter.
Second, this type of letter helps paint a fuller picture of the defendant by bringing focus onto aspects beyond what happened during one misguided moment.
The goal here is to humanize – create an image of the defendant showcasing other sides of them and demonstrating the full depth of their character instead of just focusing on the criminal act. The hope is that this, in turn, will convince the court to treat the defendant with leniency. These letters may be written in misdemeanor or felony cases.
Use Specific Anecdotes Over General Praise
Broad compliments and generic praise won’t be as impactful to a judge as sharing specific instances that exhibit the defendant’s genuine character in everyday life. Vague admiration fails to provide a clear understanding of who they are outside their charges.
When choosing anecdotes, select those moments that emphasize their kindness, remorsefulness, integrity, or personal growth—attributes opposite of what led them to legal troubles in the first place.
Sharing such meaningful stories can symbolize their potential for positive change and chances at rehabilitation more than hollow praises.
Address the Impact on the Defendant’s Support Network
It can be helpful to address how a severe penalty could impact the defendant’s community or family.
Maybe they’re someone’s sole caregiver, a contributing member of local organizations, or have young children relying heavily upon them. While this alone won’t be the deciding factor for the court, it’s something they might consider.
Maintain Respect For the Court
Another integral aspect involves maintaining respect for the judicial system, no matter your sentiment regarding the defendant’s charges. Avoid contesting verdicts, questioning justice, or professing innocence – this isn’t the purpose of character letters.
Your aim should be to provide insights about the defendant respectfully without suggesting that the court’s judgment is flawed in any manner.
Respect the Judge’s Time
Judges have busy schedules filled with numerous cases. Therefore, make every attempt to be concise in your letter without sacrificing essential details.
Aim for clarity, ensuring that your motivations for writing and relationship with the defendant are explained right at the outset; judges shouldn’t be left trying to decipher anything.
Write efficiently—every sentence should add value to the overall impression of the defendant’s character.
Align Your Expectations with Reality
When you make an appeal or “ask” in a character letter, it’s critical to keep it realistic by considering the nature of the offense and associated potential sentences. For example, asking for probation when the defendant is facing decades in jail for a murder charge is not likely to be successful.
You can still highlight any actions or efforts made by the defendant towards rehabilitation and change. This can include attending relevant treatment programs, engaging in community service, seeking counseling, or showing remorse.
Make sure you don’t overstep, though. It’s the defendant’s lawyer’s job to handle appeals and deal with unfair sentences.
Consult the Defendant’s Legal Representative
Lastly, communicate with the defendant’s lawyer before you submit your letter. Attorneys have seen many of these and understand what specific elements could sway a judge in favor of their client. Letters can be impactful, but only when crafted with care.
If you have any questions or need help with a criminal matter, contact us to schedule a free consultation with a criminal defense lawyer.
Contact Our Criminal Defense Law Firm of Ahmed & Sukaram, Attorneys at Law Today For Help.
Ahmed & Sukaram, Attorneys at Law – San Jose Office
1625 The Alameda, Suite 405 San Jose, CA 95126
Ahmed & Sukaram, Attorneys at Law – Redwood City Office
600 Allerton St Suite 201G, Redwood City, CA 94063